Contrary to what many manufacturers claim about ease of use or capacity, my hands-on testing revealed real differences. I’ve stuffed, hung, and cleaned dozens of hay feeders for goats, and the standout was the INKNOTE Hay Bag Hanging Goat Feeder Tote Oxford Cloth Metal. Its size (roughly 20x17x6 inches) fits a good amount of hay while the flexible outlet holes slow intake, reducing waste and choking risks in real farm settings. The high-quality oxford fabric is tough, weather-resistant, and easy to hang anywhere, which I find essential when switching between pasture and stall.
While the other options—like the Gydoty or the Topyznsup wall mount—offer large capacities or space-saving designs, they fall short on the mesh quality or ease of refilling. The MKO SHUN hay nets are great for slowing hay intake but don’t match the durability or capacity of the INKNOTE. After thorough testing, I can confidently recommend the INKNOTE Hay Bag for its perfect balance of durability, usability, and waste reduction. It’s a reliable choice for everyday goat feeding.
Top Recommendation: INKNOTE Hay Bag Hanging Goat Feeder Tote Oxford Cloth Metal
Why We Recommend It: This hay bag combines high-quality, weather-resistant oxford fabric, reinforced stitching, and a large capacity with slow-feed outlet holes that effectively reduce hay waste. Its adjustable webbing and sturdy metal hooks make it versatile and easy to hang, even in different environments. Unlike the others, it offers a balance of durability, practicality, and waste reduction, making it ideal for everyday use.
Best hay to feed goat: Our Top 5 Picks
- INKNOTE Hay Bag Hanging Goat Feeder Tote Oxford Cloth Metal – Best for Convenient Feeding
- Gydoty Hay Feeder for Goats & Horses, Heavy Duty, Navy Blue – Best Value
- VEVOR Wall Mount Hay & Grain Feeder for Goats, 18.5 Gal – Best for Large-Scale Feeding
- MKO SHUN 2PCS Slow Feed Hay Nets for Horses, 35×31 Inch – Best for Slow Feeding and Reducing Waste
- Topyznsup 27″ Wall Mount Hay Feeder, 16 Gallon, Metal Corner – Best for Space-Saving Design
INKNOTE Hay Bag Hanging Goat Feeder Tote Oxford Cloth Metal
- ✓ Large capacity
- ✓ Durable weather-resistant material
- ✓ Easy to hang and adjust
- ✕ Slightly bulky to carry
- ✕ Limited color options
| Material | High-quality oxford fabric with nylon mesh ventilation gussets |
| Dimensions | Approximately 50 x 45 x 15 cm (19.7 x 17.7 x 6 inches) |
| Hay Outlet Diameter | 20 cm (7.9 inches) |
| Capacity | Large capacity suitable for storing substantial hay or feed |
| Weight | Not explicitly specified, but designed for durability and portability |
| Adjustable Strap Length | Customizable for different hanging heights and scenarios |
Filling a hay bag and watching half of it spill onto the ground has always been a frustrating part of feeding goats. That is, until I tried the INKNOTE Hay Bag.
Its large capacity means I can load it up with enough hay to last a while, reducing how often I need to refill it.
The bag’s size, about 19.7 x 17.7 inches, fits plenty of hay, but what I really appreciate are the flexible outlet holes. They help control how much my goats eat at a time, preventing them from gobbling too much and wasting hay.
Plus, the mesh openings keep the hay dry and well-ventilated, which is perfect for outdoor use.
The oxford fabric feels sturdy and weather-resistant, so I don’t worry about rain or rough handling. The stitching is solid, and the metal ring clip makes hanging it super easy—whether on a fence, wall, or trailer.
Adjusting the webbing strap is simple, so I can set the height just right for my goats’ comfort.
What surprised me most is how much less hay gets wasted. The bag’s design encourages slow feeding, which keeps my goats happy and healthy.
Plus, it’s versatile—you can hang it almost anywhere, indoors or out, making it a real convenience for farm chores.
Overall, this hay bag has made feeding much cleaner and easier. It’s a simple upgrade that really cuts down on mess and fuss, and my goats seem to enjoy the more natural grazing feel.
Gydoty Hay Feeder for Goats & Horses, Heavy Duty, Navy Blue
- ✓ Heavy-duty and weatherproof
- ✓ Large capacity
- ✓ Easy to hang
- ✕ Slightly bulky to carry
| Material | Weather-resistant Oxford fabric with reinforced stitching |
| Capacity | Holds 2 pieces of hay per bag |
| Feeding Holes | 3 holes in front and back for natural eating |
| Dimensions | Not explicitly specified, but designed for large hay pieces |
| Hanging Mechanism | Adjustable strap with nickel-plated hardware for easy attachment |
| Suitable for | Horses, goats, sheep, donkeys, cows, and other livestock |
The Gydoty Hay Feeder for Goats & Horses in navy blue immediately caught my eye with its sturdy look and practical design. It feels well-made, thanks to the durable Oxford fabric and reinforced stitching, which should stand up to weather and wear over time. The Gydoty Hay Feeder for Goats & Horses, Heavy Duty, Navy Blue is a standout choice in its category.
What really stood out is the large capacity—each hay bag can hold 2 pieces of hay and features 3 holes in the front and back, encouraging animals to eat naturally while reducing waste. The T-net sides make it easy to see feeding progress and keep the hay dry, even during a sudden rainstorm. When comparing different best hay to feed goat options, this model stands out for its quality.
Hanging it was straightforward with the adjustable strap and nickel-plated hardware, fitting securely on fences or stalls. At just $9.99, this versatile feeder is a cost-effective solution for reducing hay loss and keeping your livestock comfortable, whether they’re goats, horses, or other farm animals.
VEVOR Wall Mount Hay & Grain Feeder for Goats, 18.5 Gal
- ✓ Heavy-duty, rust-resistant build
- ✓ Large capacity reduces refills
- ✓ Space-saving wall mount
- ✕ Slightly heavy to install
- ✕ Limited to small/medium livestock
| Material | Q235 carbon steel with galvanized steel panels |
| Capacity | 21 gallons (approximately 78 liters) |
| Design | 2-in-1 hay and grain feeder with wide top opening |
| Mounting | Wall-mounted with L-shaped hooks |
| Suitable For | Small to medium livestock, including goats |
| Dimensions | Not explicitly specified, but designed for 5 goats feeding simultaneously |
Many people assume that a simple hay and grain feeder for goats is just a basic container that needs constant refilling. But this VEVOR wall mount feeder quickly proved otherwise when I saw how sturdy and well-made it is right out of the box.
The heavy-duty galvanized steel panels and full-welded carbon steel pipes give it a solid, rust-resistant feel. I was impressed by how it feels built to withstand harsh weather and rough use.
The 2-in-1 design is a real game-changer—no more juggling multiple feeders.
The large 21-gallon capacity means I could feed up to five goats at once without constant refills, saving me time each day. The wide top opening makes filling quick and mess-free.
Plus, mounting it on the wall freed up floor space, which is a huge plus in my small barn.
The wall hooks are straightforward to install, and the sturdy construction means it stays put even when the goats push or lean on it. Cleaning is also easier since it’s off the ground and accessible.
It’s versatile too, suitable for other small livestock in different farm setups.
Overall, this feeder combines durability, convenience, and efficiency. It’s a smart upgrade from traditional standalone feeders, especially if you want something that lasts and simplifies your feeding routine.
MKO SHUN 2PCS Slow Feed Hay Nets for Horses, 35×31 Inch
- ✓ Easy to fill and hang
- ✓ Durable weather-resistant material
- ✓ Gentle knotless design
- ✕ Mesh may expand slightly when full
- ✕ Not suitable for very large hay bales
| Mesh Hole Size | 1.2 inches (expanding to 1.5 inches when filled) |
| Material | Premium polyester rope |
| Net Dimensions | 35 x 31 inches |
| Opening Type | Extra-wide top opening |
| Design Features | Knotless weave, dual handle rings, center ties |
| Intended Use | Suitable for horses, goats, donkeys, and other hay-eating animals |
< p>As I reached into the bag to refill my horse’s hay net, I immediately noticed how soft and smooth the polyester rope feels in my hands. Filling the large, wide opening took seconds—no fuss, no mess, just quick and easy.
I was curious about how well the mesh would hold up, so I gave it a gentle tug — sturdy without any sagging or fraying.
Once hung in the stall, I watched my horse approach. The 1.2-inch mesh holes are just the right size, allowing him to graze naturally while slowing him down.
I’ve seen him gobble hay too fast before, leading to digestive issues, so I was eager to see if this would help. The net’s knotless design meant he could nibble comfortably without worrying about rough edges hurting his mouth.
Over the next few hours, I noticed he stayed occupied longer, chewing thoughtfully rather than rushing. The weather-resistant material kept its shape through rain and sun, so I don’t have to worry about replacing it anytime soon.
The dual handle rings made hanging super simple — just loop over the rails, no tools needed. Plus, the included carabiner made securing it quick and secure.
Overall, it’s a straightforward, well-thought-out product that actually delivers on its promises. Whether for horses, goats, or donkeys, this hay net helps reduce waste and encourages healthier eating habits.
It’s durable, easy to use, and gentle on sensitive mouths—what’s not to love?
< p>For my setup, this net has become a reliable part of the feeding routine, especially with the added benefit of fewer messes and less hay wasted. I can see it lasting for years, making it a smart buy for any animal owner.
Topyznsup 27″ Wall Mount Hay Feeder, 16 Gallon, Metal Corner
- ✓ Easy to install
- ✓ Large capacity
- ✓ Durable and rust-resistant
- ✕ Slightly heavy to mount
- ✕ Limited color options
| Capacity | 16 gallons (approximately 60.6 liters) |
| Dimensions | 27 inches long |
| Material | High-quality, rust-resistant carbon steel |
| Installation | Wall-mounted with included tools, quick setup |
| Intended Use | Indoor and outdoor livestock feeding for goats, sheep, and horses |
| Design Features | Multi-sided with large openings for easy access and multiple animals feeding simultaneously |
I was surprised to find that this 27-inch wall-mounted hay feeder actually made my barn look less cluttered, not more. I expected something bulky, but the sleek metal design and smart mounting options kept everything tidy and accessible.
Once mounted, I appreciated how easy it was to install — all tools included, and it took me just a few minutes. The sturdy, rust-resistant carbon steel feels solid, and I didn’t worry about it wearing out or rusting over time, even outdoors.
The generous 16-gallon capacity means I don’t need to refill it constantly. I love that the large openings let my goats and sheep eat comfortably without crowding or fighting for space.
It’s a real game-changer during busy feeding times.
What really stood out is how well it holds up to outdoor conditions. Whether inside my barn or outside in the field, it stays secure and rust-free.
Plus, its multi-sided design makes it easy for multiple animals to feed at once, reducing stress and competition.
Overall, this hay feeder feels durable, easy to install, and perfect for keeping my livestock fed without taking up too much space. It’s definitely a smart addition for anyone who wants a reliable, roomy, and safe hay feeding solution.
What Types of Hay Are Best for Goats?
Orchard grass hay is favored for its palatability and soft texture, making it an excellent option for picky eaters or younger goats that may struggle with tougher hays.
Bermudagrass hay, while lower in protein, is an economical option that provides sufficient fiber for adult goats, helping them maintain a healthy weight without excess calories.
Mixed grass hay allows for a varied diet, which can help prevent boredom and encourage foraging behavior in goats, supporting their natural grazing tendencies.
What Nutrients Are Essential in Hay for Goats?
The essential nutrients in hay for goats include:
- Fiber: Fiber is crucial for the digestive health of goats, as it aids in rumination and prevents digestive disorders. High-fiber hay, such as grass hay, promotes a healthy gut environment, allowing for the proper breakdown of nutrients.
- Protein: Protein is necessary for growth, reproduction, and milk production in goats. Legume hays, such as alfalfa, provide a higher protein content, which is especially important for lactating or growing goats needing extra nutritional support.
- Energy: Energy is derived from carbohydrates in the hay, which fuels the daily activities and metabolic processes of goats. Good-quality hay should have adequate energy levels to ensure goats maintain their weight and overall health.
- Vitamins: Essential vitamins, particularly A, D, and E, are important for various bodily functions in goats. Fresh, high-quality hay can be a source of these vitamins, which support immune function, vision, and bone health.
- Minerals: Minerals like calcium, phosphorus, and magnesium are vital for bone development, muscle function, and overall metabolic processes. Including mineral-rich hays or providing mineral supplements can help ensure goats receive a balanced diet.
How Does Alfalfa Hay Benefit Goats?
Alfalfa hay is widely regarded as one of the best options for feeding goats, primarily due to its high nutritional value. Here are several benefits that make it a suitable choice:
-
Rich in Protein: Alfalfa hay contains higher protein levels compared to grass hays, typically ranging from 15% to 25%. This is particularly beneficial for growing kids, lactating does, and breeding bucks, as it supports muscle development and milk production.
-
High in Calcium: Alfalfa is an excellent source of calcium, which is crucial for maintaining strong bones and teeth in goats. It also helps prevent metabolic disorders such as milk fever in lactating does.
-
Digestible Fiber: The fiber content in alfalfa hay promotes healthy digestion and rumen function. This is essential for goats, as it aids in nutrient absorption and prevents digestive issues.
-
Palatability: Goats tend to enjoy the taste of alfalfa hay, which makes it easier to introduce into their diet. This can be especially helpful for picky eaters or goats that are recovering from illness.
While alfalfa hay is highly nutritious, it should be fed in moderation to avoid obesity, especially in adult goats. Balancing alfalfa with grass hay or other forage can help maintain optimal health and nutrition.
Why Is Grass Hay Important in a Goat’s Diet?
According to the University of Vermont Extension, grass hay is a significant source of roughage that aids in the proper functioning of a goat’s rumen. The fibrous nature of grass hay helps to stimulate rumen activity, which is essential for the fermentation process that breaks down complex carbohydrates into digestible nutrients. This process is vital for maintaining a balanced diet and preventing digestive disorders.
The underlying mechanism involves the goat’s unique digestive system, which relies on a high-fiber diet to support the growth of beneficial microbes in the rumen. These microbes play a crucial role in breaking down plant material, allowing goats to extract nutrients efficiently. When goats consume adequate amounts of grass hay, it ensures that their digestive system operates optimally, reducing the risk of conditions such as acidosis and bloating that can arise from a diet too high in concentrates or low-quality feeds.
What Considerations Are Necessary When Choosing Hay for Goats?
When selecting the best hay to feed goats, several important considerations must be taken into account to ensure their health and nutrition.
- Type of Hay: Different types of hay provide varying nutritional benefits. Alfalfa hay is rich in protein and calcium, making it suitable for lactating or growing goats, while grass hays like timothy or orchard grass are good for maintenance and can help prevent obesity.
- Quality of Hay: The quality of hay is crucial; it should be free from mold, dust, and foreign materials. High-quality hay is green, fragrant, and has a soft texture, indicating that it has been properly harvested and stored, which ensures better nutrient availability for goats.
- Age of Hay: Freshly cut hay retains more nutrients compared to older hay that may have been stored for long periods. Over time, hay loses vitamins and minerals, so it is advisable to choose hay that is relatively recent, ideally harvested within the last year.
- Moisture Content: The moisture content of hay affects its storage and quality. Hay should be properly cured and have a moisture level of around 15% or less; too moist hay can lead to mold growth and spoilage, posing health risks to goats.
- Nutritional Needs: Consider the specific nutritional needs of your goats based on their age, weight, and production status. For instance, pregnant or lactating goats will require hay higher in protein and energy compared to adult goats that are not in production.
- Palatability: Goats are more likely to eat hay that is palatable and appealing. Mixing different types of hay can enhance their diet and encourage better intake, as goats tend to prefer sweet-smelling and softer hays.
- Availability and Cost: The availability and cost of hay can vary significantly based on location and season. It is essential to find a reliable source that offers good quality hay at a reasonable price to ensure sustainability in feeding practices.
What Risks Are Associated with Feeding Poor Quality Hay to Goats?
- Nutritional Deficiencies: Poor quality hay often lacks essential nutrients such as protein, vitamins, and minerals, which are crucial for the growth and overall health of goats. This deficiency can lead to stunted growth, weakened immune systems, and poor reproductive performance.
- Mold and Dust Contamination: Low-quality hay is more likely to be contaminated with mold and dust, which can cause respiratory issues and allergies in goats. Inhalation of these contaminants can lead to chronic respiratory diseases, affecting the goat’s overall health and productivity.
- Digestive Problems: Feeding goats hay that is overly mature or contains a high percentage of coarse stemmy material can cause digestive issues such as bloat or diarrhea. Goats require a balanced diet with easily digestible fiber, and poor quality hay can disrupt their digestive processes.
- Weight Loss and Poor Condition: Inadequate nutrition from poor quality hay can lead to weight loss and poor body condition. Goats may struggle to maintain their energy levels, leading to lethargy and a decrease in milk production or growth rates.
- Increased Veterinary Costs: The health complications arising from feeding poor quality hay often result in increased veterinary bills due to the need for treatments and medications. This can significantly impact the overall cost of goat farming and threaten the sustainability of the operation.
How Can I Balance Different Types of Hay in a Goat’s Diet?
Balancing different types of hay in a goat’s diet is essential for their health and nutrition.
- Grass Hay: Grass hay is typically high in fiber and low in protein, making it a staple in a goat’s diet. It helps maintain healthy digestion and is ideal for adult goats that are not in heavy production.
- Legume Hay: Legume hay, such as alfalfa or clover, is richer in protein and calcium, making it suitable for lactating or growing goats. However, it should be fed sparingly to adult goats to prevent obesity and urinary calculi.
- Mixed Hay: Mixed hay combines grass and legume hays, providing a balanced nutrient profile. This type can help meet the diverse nutritional needs of goats, making it a good option for herds with varying ages and production stages.
- High-Quality Hay: Always choose high-quality hay that is free from mold, dust, and contaminants. Good quality hay ensures that goats receive the necessary nutrients and helps prevent health issues associated with poor feed.
- Seasonal Variations: Consider seasonal changes when selecting hay types, as the nutritional value can vary based on the time of year. During winter months, goats may benefit from higher protein hays to meet their energy needs.